El control ex post de la calidad de los enunciados probatorios en materia penal en Chile. De la epistemología a la praxis

Abstract

Is the control of de conclusions concerning the acts of the nullity courts in a system of freedom of evidence possible? This question arises because it is usually stated, that the audit of the quaestio facti made by judges that were not present in the oral trial is not possible, and because the liberty in emphasized,and not the subjection that, on the activity matter, must be made to the cannon of the general epistemology. Consequently, this investigation contemplates the improvement of the subjetive approach and the appel to the epistemological approach of the evaluative activity and its control, using the standard of proofing and justification of de decision, through the recourse of nullity, which also allows to perfectly meet the guarantee of the right to the recourse

Demostrar que es posible el control de las conclusiones probatorias por los tribunales de nulidad en un sistema de libertad de prueba es el objetivo central del trabajo. Se plantea la superación del enclave subjetivista y el recurso al enfoque epistemológico de la actividad valorativa y su control, recurriendo al estándar de prueba y la justificación de la decisión, por el cauce del recurso de nulidad, lo que permite cumplir con la garantía del derecho al recurso